Napa or Sonoma? How the Two Wine Regions Differ for a First Trip

Posted by ONEHOPE Winery on

Napa Valley is a single valley whose floor is roughly 25 to 30 miles long and only a few miles wide. Sonoma County, directly west across the Mayacamas Mountains, is more than twice the size of Napa County, takes in several valleys and reaches the coast.

Neither region is the better choice for a first trip. Napa suits a trip built around one valley and its signature grape, Cabernet Sauvignon. Sonoma suits one built around variety, with several valleys, a wider range of wines and a coastline. The two counties sit side by side, so one trip can take in both, and the Los Carneros appellation lies in the south of each.

At a glance

  • Where: Sonoma County lies directly west of Napa County, across the Mayacamas Mountains.
  • Size: Napa County covers about 790 square miles; Sonoma County is more than twice that size.
  • Coast: Sonoma County has about 76 miles of Pacific coastline. Napa County has none.
  • Appellations: seventeen smaller appellations lie inside Napa Valley, and Sonoma County has nineteen. Los Carneros belongs to both.
  • Grapes: Cabernet Sauvignon grows on roughly half of Napa's vineyard land. Sonoma's most planted grapes are Chardonnay, Cabernet Sauvignon and Pinot Noir.

Napa or Sonoma: what is the short answer?

The answer turns on layout and on what you want to taste, not on which region ranks higher.

  • Choose Napa if you want one valley between two mountain ranges, with its towns strung along a single main road from south to north.
  • Choose Sonoma if you want a larger county of several valleys, from Sonoma Valley in the south-east to the Russian River and the coast.

How do Napa and Sonoma compare?

The Napa Valley appellation covers all of Napa County except the part north-east of Putah Creek and Lake Berryessa. So the table sets county beside county.

Napa Sonoma
Size Napa County: about 790 square miles Sonoma County: more than twice the size of Napa County
Layout One main valley, its floor roughly 25 to 30 miles long, between the Mayacamas Mountains on the west and the Vaca Mountains on the east Several valleys and areas, among them Sonoma Valley, the Petaluma Valley, the Santa Rosa Plain, the Russian River, the Alexander Valley and the Dry Creek Valley
Coast No ocean coastline; the south end opens onto San Pablo Bay About 76 miles of Pacific coastline on the west
Towns Along Highway 29, south to north: American Canyon, Napa, Yountville, Oakville, Rutherford, St. Helena and Calistoga; the county seat is the city of Napa Nine incorporated cities: Cloverdale, Cotati, Healdsburg, Petaluma, Rohnert Park, Santa Rosa, Sebastopol, Sonoma and Windsor; the county seat is Santa Rosa
Appellations Seventeen smaller appellations inside Napa Valley Nineteen in Sonoma County
Signature grapes Cabernet Sauvignon, on roughly half the vineyard land Chardonnay, Cabernet Sauvignon and Pinot Noir are the most planted
Summer climate Hot and dry; the south, open to the bay, is cooler, and the sheltered north is often much warmer Varies a great deal from place to place, with cooler, foggier conditions nearer the ocean
Roads and areas Highway 29 and the Silverado Trail run up the valley, linked by cross roads Several separate areas: Sonoma Valley in the south-east, and the Russian River watershed across much of the central and northern county

The two appellation counts measure different things. Napa's seventeen sit inside the Napa Valley appellation, while Sonoma's nineteen are the appellations of the county. Both counties share Los Carneros. Our guide to Napa Valley's seventeen appellations describes each one.

How do the wines differ?

Cabernet Sauvignon leads in Napa. It is the valley's signature and most widely planted grape, grown on roughly half of Napa's vineyard land.

Napa grows other grapes too: Merlot, Cabernet Franc, Pinot Noir, Zinfandel, Chardonnay and Sauvignon Blanc, among others. Many Napa wines blend grapes from the valley floor and the surrounding hillsides.

Sonoma is known for a wider range of wines, Pinot Noir and Chardonnay among them. Its most planted grapes are Chardonnay, Cabernet Sauvignon and Pinot Noir, so Cabernet grows on both sides of the mountains.

Napa Valley has a Mediterranean climate, with hot, dry summers and cool, wet winters. On a typical July afternoon, average highs run about 79°F near the city of Napa, about 89°F at St. Helena and about 90°F at Calistoga.

Sonoma County's climate varies a great deal from place to place, with cooler, foggier conditions nearer the ocean.

Where the two counties meet, Los Carneros lies just north of San Pablo Bay, in southern Napa and southern Sonoma. Cool and bay-influenced, it suits Pinot Noir and Chardonnay, and its grapes also go into sparkling wine.

For flavor and food, each grape has its own guide: our Cabernet Sauvignon guide, Pinot Noir guide and Chardonnay guide.

Which suits a first trip?

Either suits a first trip; what differs is the layout you plan around.

Napa is one valley with two main roads. Highway 29 runs north through the towns, and the Silverado Trail runs about 29 miles along the eastern side of the valley floor.

Cross roads such as the Oakville Cross Road and Rutherford Road link the two. The Silverado Trail is often quieter than Highway 29, where traffic can be heavy, especially in spring and summer.

Sonoma County spreads wider. Sonoma Valley, its south-eastern part, runs from San Pablo Bay north toward Santa Rosa, between the Mayacamas Mountains and the Sonoma Mountains.

The town of Sonoma sits in that valley and is the center of the Sonoma Valley appellation. It has a central plaza, with its city hall in the middle.

Beyond Sonoma Valley lie the other valleys and areas in the table, from the Petaluma Valley to the Alexander Valley. Much of central and northern Sonoma County lies in the Russian River's watershed.

Keep the names apart. Sonoma County is the county, Sonoma Valley is one valley in it, and the town of Sonoma is a city in that valley. The county seat is Santa Rosa.

For the Napa side in full, read where Napa Valley is, with its towns and its two main roads.

In both counties, you must be 21 or older to taste. Driving under the influence is illegal in California, so plan a driver or a car service and never drive after tasting.

Can you visit both on one trip?

Yes. Sonoma County lies directly west of Napa County, across the Mayacamas Mountains, so the two regions sit side by side.

At the south end, Los Carneros links them: the appellation lies in both counties.

Plan a few visits in a day, with time for lunch and the road between.

Our guide to getting to Napa Valley covers the airports and the roads.

So which should you choose?

  • Choose Napa if you want one valley to learn well, two main roads to plan around and Cabernet Sauvignon, its signature grape, in the glass.
  • Choose Sonoma if you want several valleys to explore, Pinot Noir and Chardonnay beside Cabernet Sauvignon, and a county that reaches the coast.

If your first trip is to Napa, ONEHOPE Wine's winery and tasting room, ONEHOPE Winery, is in Rutherford, Napa Valley. Visits are by reservation, and guests must be 21 or older. Book a visit.

Questions people ask

Is Napa or Sonoma better for a first trip?

Neither is better; they suit different trips. Napa is one valley whose signature grape is Cabernet Sauvignon. Sonoma County is more than twice the size of Napa County, with several valleys, a coastline and a wider range of wines.

What is the difference between Napa and Sonoma wine?

Cabernet Sauvignon grows on roughly half of Napa's vineyard land. Sonoma's most planted grapes are Chardonnay, Cabernet Sauvignon and Pinot Noir. Los Carneros, shared by both counties, suits Pinot Noir and Chardonnay.

Is Sonoma bigger than Napa?

Yes. Sonoma County is more than twice the size of Napa County, which covers about 790 square miles. Sonoma County also has about 76 miles of Pacific coastline, and Napa County has none.

Can you do Napa and Sonoma in one day?

Yes. The two counties sit side by side across the Mayacamas Mountains, and Los Carneros lies in the south of both. Plan a few visits in a day, with time for lunch and the road between, and choose a few stops across the two. Plan a driver or a car service; never drive after tasting.

Is Napa or Sonoma known for Pinot Noir?

Sonoma is known for a wider range of wines, Pinot Noir and Chardonnay among them. Pinot Noir is one of Sonoma County's three most planted grapes. Napa grows Pinot Noir too, and cool Carneros at its south end suits it. In Napa, Cabernet Sauvignon is the signature grape, grown on roughly half of its vineyard land.

← Older Post Newer Post →

News

RSS
ONEHOPE Winery in Rutherford at dusk: a timber building with tall windows behind a low lit wall, wooded hills beyond
napa valley

Your First Napa Tasting Room Visit: Reservations, Etiquette and Pacing

By ONEHOPE Winery

Most Napa tasting rooms ask you to reserve ahead, tastings are for guests 21 and over, and a host pours small samples and answers your...

Read more
A hand with red-handled shears cuts a cluster of dark grapes from a vine in an Oakville vineyard
napa valley wine education

What Is an AVA? American Wine Regions on a Label, Explained

By ONEHOPE Winery

An AVA is an officially designated American wine grape-growing region, and its name on a label means at least 85 percent of the grapes grew...

Read more